Eli Manning has led his Giants to the Super Bowl and done so quicker than his older brother Peyton. At this point in time Peyton has a Super Bowl ring while brother Eli has just arrived to the Super Bowl, but let's start to compare the two quarterbacks.
Understanding the Game:
There's no question that Peyton Manning can dissect and carve up any defense with patience and skill. The Colts allow Peyton to call his own plays. Eli can still be very erratic and throw passes into the teeth of the defensive coverage.
Advantage - Peyton
Leadership:
Without question both sides of the ball look to Peyton to lead them to victory. Eli is still finding his way. It's the Giants defense that carries the load.
Advantage Peyton
Battle of TV Ads:
This is a slam dunk for Peyton. How can you not like his "pep" talks, his mustache commercial, his advertisement for TV's sitting on the couch, and even his sports center commercials? He also gets the last good shot on brother Eli in this sport center spot.
Advantage Peyton:
A Hypothetical Entourage Endorsement - Turtle & Drama:
Most likely Turtle would want to party with Peyton in the hopes of picking up some honeys. Johnny "Drama" on the other hand is very loyal and would probably side with Eli as he plays for his hometown Giants.
Advantage Eli - c'mon Johnny "Drama" helps make the show what it is.

